Key Points:
Robinhood is breaking barriers by bringing more retail investors into the futures market.
Event contracts unlock new ways to make real-time, data-driven decisions, democratizing market access.
The CFTC’s broad proposal to prohibit event contracts risks stifling innovation and limiting opportunities for investors.
Robinhood advocates for balanced, thoughtful regulation to protect market integrity while fostering growth.
Futures and event contracts are unlocking new opportunities for risk management and speculation across industries. From agriculture to politics to economic indicators, businesses and individuals are using these tools to navigate uncertainty and generate income. For example:
A farmer might hedge against a poor crop yield.
A business might hedge against potential policy shifts tied to the outcome of a presidential election.
A manufacturer might hedge against rising costs linked to the Consumer Price Index (CPI).
However, the CFTC’s 2024 proposed rule to prohibit event contracts—especially those related to gaming—threatens to undermine these innovations. By defining event contracts in an overly broad and ambiguous way, the proposal risks eliminating tools that enable legitimate risk management without providing sufficient economic justification. This approach could have significant negative impacts on the market:
Stifling Innovation: Futures markets thrive on the ability to introduce new, market-driven products. The CFTC’s proposal risks deterring the development of tools that offer meaningful economic value.
Ignoring Key Stakeholders: The proposal primarily considers the impact on large, established entities like exchanges and clearinghouses but fails to recognize how it could negatively affect retail investors and small businesses who rely on these contracts for risk management and new market opportunities.
Retail investors should retain the ability to make their own investment decisions, a principle that has long underpinned the futures markets. The current self-certification process, which allows market participants to introduce products based on their viability, has effectively supported innovation for decades. Banning certain products under this proposal represents an unwarranted and imprudent departure from that practice.If any new regulations for event contracts are necessary, they should:
Align with the regulatory framework for other futures products, ensuring consistency and fairness.
Preserve investor choice and self-certification by CFTC-regulated market participants.
Encourage innovation to avoid pushing the event-contracts business to overseas markets with weaker consumer protections.
Prohibiting event contracts unnecessarily stifles innovation and undermines consumer choice. The CFTC should withdraw this proposal to protect the principles of market-driven innovation and self-direction that have historically benefited investors and the broader financial system.
At Robinhood Derivatives, we are committed to ensuring that the futures and derivatives markets remain innovative, inclusive, and accessible. To this end, we’ve taken significant steps to advocate for balanced regulation:
Engaging Directly with Regulators: JB Mackenzie, Vice President and General Manager of Futures and International at Robinhood, participated in a CFTC roundtable where he highlighted the importance of a regulatory framework that fosters innovation while supporting diverse market opportunities.
Providing Written Feedback: Robinhood submitted a detailed comment letter to the CFTC, outlining the risks posed by the proposed rule and urging the Commission to reconsider.
Advocating for Retail Investors: We continue to champion the economic benefits of event contracts, highlighting their role in expanding access and enabling real-time decision-making for retail customers.
Our approach reflects Robinhood’s broader mission: to democratize access to financial tools and create opportunities for retail investors to participate in innovative markets.
We envision a regulatory framework that:
Supports Innovation: By encouraging market-driven solutions, regulators can foster new products that offer economic value to all participants.
Provides Clarity: Clear, precise definitions are essential to ensure legitimate contracts are not inadvertently prohibited.
Balances Consumer Protection and Market Growth: Thoughtful, data-driven policies can maintain market integrity while expanding access.
Futures and event contracts have the potential to transform how investors engage with markets, offering powerful tools for real-time risk management and strategic speculation. Robinhood is dedicated to shaping a regulatory framework that not only safeguards these opportunities but also upholds the integrity and trust in the financial system. By championing innovation and responsibility, we can ensure that futures and event contracts thrive as a dynamic and essential pillar of the modern financial ecosystem.
4152856